How did humans invent war? - transcript

 

(2) How Did Humans Invent War? - YouTube


Transcripts:

(00:00) A skeleton is kept in a museum in Khartoum . It belongs to a person who lived approximately 13,400 years ago in the Nile Valley in what is now northern Sudan.  A stone tip was stuck in the left side of the chest , it wasn't just lying next to the bones. It entered living tissue with such force that it embedded itself in the bone.

(00:20)   And here's a fact that won't let you sleep tonight.  This person survived.  The wound has healed.  The bone has grown around the stone, which means that someone later attacked this person again, because there is a second unhealed wound that became fatal.  Someone was attacked, survived, recovered, came back to life, and then was attacked again by someone else—or perhaps the same people—and this time did n't get up.

(00:46) This skeleton is 13,400 years old.  Back then, there were no countries, no borders, no flags, no armies, no generals, no declarations.  Just two groups of people who decided—for reasons we'll never know for sure—that the other group should die, and we've been doing it ever since. So, did humans invent war?  Has war always been a part of who we are?  This question has haunted philosophers , anthropologists, archaeologists, and military historians for centuries .

(01:17)   And the answer, as it turns out, depends entirely on what you mean by "war."  Because if you mean organized armies with uniforms, supply chains, and strategic goals, then this has a start date.  We can point to it .  But if you mean coordinated group violence, where one group of people intentionally kills another, then this trail stretches so far that it begins to merge with the question of what it means to be human in the first place.

(01:43)   Let's start with the bones, because bones don't lie.  That skeleton in Khartoum was found in a place called Jebel Sahaba, also known as Cemetery No. 117.  It was excavated in 1964 by archaeologist Fred Wendorf during construction work related to the Aswan Dam. Wendorf discovered a burial site containing 61 sets of human remains dating back to about 13,400 years ago and associated with a culture that archaeologists call Kadanian.

(02:11)   And these were not peaceful burials. Dozens of skeletons bore signs of violent death .  Stone projectile points , used for arrows and spears, were found embedded in bones or inside the body cavities of the deceased.  For decades, Jebel Sahaba has been called the oldest evidence of war, of a prehistoric battle, of a massacre—the first war.

(02:33)   But in 2021, paleoanthropologist Isabelle Crevcourt of the University of Bordeaux re-examined each skeleton using modern microscopic analysis, and her results, published in Scientific Reports, changed that story. Crevcourt's team discovered over 100 previously undocumented injuries on the remains. But the important detail was this.

(02:54) Many people had both healed and unhealed wounds.  The same person was attacked, survived, and then became a victim of the attack again.  Sometimes this happened several times throughout a lifetime. Men, women and children.  All of them.  It wasn't just one battle.  It was chronic, ongoing, low-intensity group violence, raids, skirmishes, and acts of retaliation that stretched over years, and perhaps generations.

(03:20)   Crevcourt's team concluded that the cause of the violence was likely climate change.    The Nile Valley was experiencing severe environmental stress at the end of the last ice age.    The water level fluctuated dramatically.  Resources have become unpredictable.  And when resources become unpredictable, people become dangerous. Think about what this means.

(03:40)   13,400 years ago: no agriculture , no cities, no state laws, just small bands of hunter-gatherers living along a river that was slowly being squeezed by a changing climate .  And their response was organized, repeated deadly violence against other groups of people.  Not a one-time outburst of rage, but a behavioral model, a strategy, a way of life.

(04:03)   Jebel Sahaba is not the only such case.  In 2012, field assistant Pedro Ebea was walking near Lake Turkana in northern Kenya when he noticed bones washing out of sedimentary rocks.  What followed was one of the most important archaeological discoveries of the 21st century.    A team led by Marta Mirazon Lahr from the University of Cambridge discovered the remains of 27 individuals dating back approximately 10,000 years.

(04:27)   They published their findings in the journal Nature in 2016.  The bodies were not buried.  They were left where they fell, in what was then a swampy lagoon on the shore of a lake.  10 skeletons had clear, undeniable signs of violent death .  Crushed skulls, broken knees, an obsidian blade still stuck in one man's skull, arrow marks in the necks of others.

(04:51) One woman was found in a position that indicated her hands were tied.  This place is called Nataruk. And that's why Nataruk matters more to this story than almost any other place.  These were not farmers.  These were not settled people defending a granary or a wall.  They were nomadic hunter-gatherers.    The traditional explanation for the emergence of war has always been that it emerged with agriculture.

(05:14)   You grow crops, stockpile food, build a village, and now you have something worth stealing.  There is property, there are borders — that is the motive for organized violence.  That was the theory.  Nataruk denied it, because these people had nothing like that.  They led a nomadic lifestyle.  They only had what they could carry, but they were killed anyway.

(05:34) Why?  We don't know. Maybe it's the territory.  The Lake Turkana area was rich in resources 10,000 years ago. Maybe it's the women or the children. Among the dead at Nataruka are adults of both sexes, but no young women, which some researchers believe indicates that they were abducted.  Or maybe it was something that could n't be recreated from bones alone.

(06:00) Revenge, enmity, resentment that built up over generations until someone decided to put an end to it forever.  But before delving into the history of humanity, we should talk about chimpanzees.  After all, the question of whether humans invented war or inherited it has its own example in the forests of East Africa.

(06:18) In 1974, primatologist Jane Goodall observed chimpanzees in Gombe Stream National Park in Tanzania.  She has studied this group for over ten years. She knew each of them personally.  She gave them names.  And then the community split.  A group of males that spent more time in the southern part of the territory separated and formed their own community.

(06:39)   The northern group was called Kasakela.  The southern splinter group was called Kahama.  What happened next changed primatology forever. Over the next four years, from 1974 to 1978, Kasakela males systematically hunted down and killed every adult male in the Kahama community. They didn't do it in one attack. They did this during coordinated raids.

(07:03)   Small groups of Kasakela males would quietly infiltrate Kahama territory, find a lone male, surround him, and beat him to death one by one.  Within four years, they killed all six adult males.  They killed at least one young male.  Several females have disappeared and are presumed dead.  By 1978, the Kahama community had ceased to exist.

(07:25) Kasakela males have expanded their territory into these lands.  Goodall was stunned. She later wrote that for many years she would wake up at night from the terrible images in her memory.  She spent decades proving that chimpanzees are intelligent , social, and emotionally complex creatures.  And now she saw them committing what could only be called war.

(07:47) Think about what the Gombe War means for the question of how humans invented war. Chimpanzees are our closest living relatives.  We share approximately 98.7% of our DNA with them.  We last had a common ancestor about 6-7 million years ago. If chimpanzees engage in coordinated, lethal territorial violence, as they apparently do, then the ability to engage in such behavior may predate the emergence of humanity as a whole.

(08:12) Maybe we didn't invent war. Maybe we inherited it.  But not everyone agrees with this conclusion.  This is where the debate becomes heated.  And it has remained that way for decades.  On the one hand, there is what scientists call the deep roots theory.  The idea that war is an evolutionary behavior , built into our biology by millions of years of natural selection.

(08:33)   The main modern proponent of this view is Lawrence Keeley, an archaeologist at the University of Illinois at Chicago, who in 1996 published the book War to Civilization: The Myth of the Peaceful Savage.  Keeley collected archaeological and ethnographic data from dozens of societies and argued that prehistoric warfare was not a rare or ritualistic phenomenon.

(08:52) It was constant, brutal, and far more deadly per capita than anything in the modern world.  His data indicate that in many pre-state societies, from 15 to 25% of men died violent deaths at the hands of other people. From 15 to 25%. Compare this to the approximately 1–2% of Europeans who died in war in the 20th century, including both world wars.

(09:15) Steven Pinker used Keeley's data in his 2011 book The Better Angels of Our Nature and built an entire argument around it .  That people become less violent over time, not the other way around, and that the modern state, for all its flaws, has become an extremely effective force for peace.  On the other hand—R.

(09:33)   Brian Ferguson, an anthropologist at Rutgers University, and Douglas Fry, who published a study in the journal Science in 2013 with Patri Soderberg. Ferguson has dedicated his career to proving that warfare is not biological.  It is cultural.  It's an invention, a technology, if you want to think of it that way, that humans developed under certain conditions, and those conditions didn't exist for most of our evolutionary history.

(09:58)   Ferguson argues that Keeley and Pinker are selective in their approach to their data.  He points out that many of the societies that Keeley cites as warlike had already been in contact with colonial powers, and that it was colonial intervention that often provoked or exacerbated the violence.  He also distinguishes between individual murder and war.

(10:15) Murder is not war .  A feud between two families is not war .  War, Ferguson argues, requires social organization, group identity, strategic planning, and the dehumanization of the enemy .  And these things, he says , are learned, not born with them.    A 2013 study by Fry and Soderbergh analyzed 148 cases of lethal aggression in 21 mobile hunter-gatherer societies— small, nomadic groups that most closely resemble the way humans lived for most of our existence.

(10:47) Their conclusion: most cases of lethal violence in these groups were personal. Individual disputes, jealousy, revenge, domestic conflicts—acts that would qualify as murder, not war. Organized group attacks on other groups accounted for a minority of murders. Their conclusion: war is not the natural state of humanity.

(11:08)   This is a specific cultural behavior that arose under the influence of certain historical circumstances. So who is right? Honestly, probably both sides.  And yet neither of them, because the evidence points to something more complicated than either side wants to admit. The capacity for group violence appears to be very ancient.

(11:27)   Chimpanzees have it.  The bones at Jebel Sahaba and Nataruk testify to this.  Something in the primate brain—some combination of territorial instinct, coalitional behavior, and the ability to classify others as “not us”—emerged tens of thousands, perhaps millions, of years before the emergence of agriculture, cities, and civilization.

(11:46)   But the capacity for violence is not the same as war.  Your neighbor has the ability to punch you in the face.  This does not mean that your area is at war.  War requires something more than just the capacity for violence.  It requires organization , logistics, leadership, a reason for the fight that is shared by the group, not just felt by an individual.

(12:07)   And these things, the infrastructure of war , really do look like they were invented, built, and developed over time in response to specific conditions.  And the most important of these conditions was this one. Having something worth fighting for that cannot be moved. For most of human history, we have been nomads.  If a neighboring group became aggressive, you could walk away, find another valley, another hunting ground.

(12:31)   Conflict was possible. Nataruk certainly proves it, but he wasn't inevitable.  Because the thing that makes war self-sustaining, that turns a raid into a campaign, is the impossibility of retreat.  And the inability to retreat came with agriculture. About 12,000 years ago, during what archaeologists call the Neolithic Revolution, people in several parts of the world began to domesticate plants and animals.  They settled down.

(12:55) They built permanent settlements. They began to accumulate surplus food.  And the moment they did, they created something that had never existed before in human history.  Real estate wealth.  A barn full of wheat cannot escape.  A herd of livestock cannot be lifted and moved to the next valley.

(13:12)   A field that took months to clear and sow cannot be abandoned without devastating damage.    For the first time, people had property that was worth protecting and worth stealing .  And the archaeological evidence reflects this. Fortified settlements begin to appear several thousand years after the emergence of the first agriculture.

(13:30)   The walls of Jericho, dating back to around 8000 BC, were long considered the first military fortifications.  Although modern scholars, such as Ofer Bar-Yosef, have argued that they may have been built for flood protection rather than defense.  But by 6000 BC. clearly recognizable defensive architecture appears in the Middle East and Europe.

(13:51)   Moats, palisades, watchtowers.  You don't build a watchtower if you're afraid of floods.  And here's something interesting about one of the earliest large settlements that we know of. Çatalhüyük in modern-day Turkey existed from approximately 7500 to 5700 BC.  There were no walls, gates, or defensive perimeter of any type.

(14:12) Instead, there was architecture that was a defense in itself .  Houses were built close together , with shared walls, without streets or doors at ground level.  You entered the house through a hole in the roof using a ladder, which meant that the entire exterior facade of the settlement was a solid wall of mud brick with no windows.

(14:31)   If you wanted to attack Çatalhöyük, you would have to climb a featureless vertical surface while people inside would throw various objects at your head .  They did not build fortifications.  They built their entire village as one unit.  And excavation data shows an extremely low level of violent trauma in skeletal remains.

(14:47)   Whatever they did, it worked. But Çatal-Hüyük also tells us something else.  The fact that a community of several thousand people specifically designed their homes to repel attackers suggests that attackers existed.  You don't build a defensible settlement if there's nothing to defend against. The architecture is proof.

(15:07)   The walls of Jericho, whether they stopped floods or armies , and the design of the roof entrance at Çatalhüyük, whether it was intentional or accidental, lead to one conclusion.  By 8000 BC.  Organized violence between groups of people became so prevalent that people literally built their lives in anticipation of it.  And then something happened that turned the raids into a war.  Hierarchy.

(15:29) The emergence of chiefs, kings, and centralized power structures that could manage resources, mobilize labor, and direct violence on a scale that no hunter-gatherer group could match. In Mesopotamia until about 3000 BC.  The first true city-states—Uruk, Lagash, Umma— competed for control of the fertile lands between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers , and they competed with organized armies.

(15:52)     The Shulik Stele, created around 2450 BC and discovered by French archaeologist Ernest de Sarzec at the site of ancient Girsu in modern-day Iraq, depicts King Eanatum of Lagash leading his warriors against the enemy city of Umma. And these warriors are not a disorganized crowd.  They march in formation, shoulder to shoulder, with shields clasped, spears drawn, and helmets on.

(16:16)   This is the earliest known depiction of the phalanx, a tactical formation that would dominate warfare for the next 2,000 years.  The stela also shows a stele carrying severed heads and limbs. This is a war monument, the earliest one known to us.  And it shows that by 2450 BC, war was not just an event that happened.  It was something that was honored, immortalized, carved in stone for future generations to admire.

(16:41)   At that time, Sumerian city- states fought among themselves with the help of citizen militias.  Farmers and workers called up for seasonal campaigns fought for several weeks and then returned home to tend their fields.  This works when your enemy is a neighboring city.  But that doesn't work when you want to build an empire.

(16:59)   And about 200 years after Eanatum, someone figured it out.  Sargon of Akkad, circa 2334 BC, is a man whose origins are still a matter of debate. Perhaps the cupbearer of King Kish, he seized power and began to conquer everything he could reach. His main innovation was not a new weapon or a new tactic.  It was a new kind of army.

(17:20)   Sargon is credited with creating the first standing professional army in history. Soldiers who didn't go home after the battle. Soldiers who trained all year round, who were fed and supported by the state, whose only calling was war.  Ancient texts claim that he maintained a detachment of 5,400 warriors who ate bread before him every day.

(17:39)   A professional army means that you can fight at any time of the year.  You can project force over vast distances.  You can hold conquered territories with the help of permanent garrisons .  Sargon used this army to create the Akkadian Empire, which stretched from the Persian Gulf to the Mediterranean Sea.  It was the first empire in history, and it stood on the shoulders of the first army that existed not to defend a city, but to conquer it.

(18:02)   This is the moment when war ceases to be a defensive reaction and becomes an instrument of politics.  What you do is not because you have to, but because you can—because you have the infrastructure, the logistics, and the standing military to do it when you decide to.  It is a transition as important as the invention of agriculture itself.

(18:22)   Because agriculture created something worth fighting for.  But regular armies created the opportunity to fight for anything, anywhere, and anytime. The standard, dated to around 2600 BC, goes back even further .  One side, which modern scholars have called "war," shows war chariots drawn by onagrams trampling enemies, infantry in formation, and prisoners being led to the king.

(18:45) The other side, "peace," shows a banquet with musicians.  War and peace were already perceived as two sides of the same political coin 4,600 years ago.  And about a thousand years later, the first battle took place that we can reconstruct in detail.  In 1457 BC.    In 1111, the Egyptian pharaoh Thutmose III led his army through the narrow mountain pass of Arun against the advice of his generals to surprise a coalition of Canaanite forces camped near the fortress city of Megiddo.

(19:15)   His military scribe, Janeni, recorded the entire campaign on the walls of the Temple of Amun-Ra at Karnak. Troop movement, supply logistics . Pharaoh's tactical decisions.  The Battle of Megiddo is the first battle in recorded history for which there is a detailed and reliable description.  This is the moment when war ceases to be something we infer from bones and stone monuments, and becomes something we can read about in the words of the people who participated in it .

(19:41)   But between the first raids and the first recorded battles, something noteworthy changed .  Weapons have changed , and the way they have changed says a lot about how war has evolved from an occasional calamity to a permanent institution. For hundreds of thousands of years, human weapons have been tools adapted for violence.

(19:59)   A spear is a hunting tool.    A bow is a hunting tool.  An axe is a forestry tool.  They can, of course, kill a person, but they were not created for that purpose.  And there is something psychologically important in this difference .  When you kill someone with a hunting spear, you are using a survival tool for a different purpose.

(20:17)   When you kill someone with a weapon designed specifically for that purpose, something has changed.  You have created an object whose sole reason for existence is the death of another person. This is no longer survival. This is preparation.  The first object designed specifically and exclusively for killing another human being, as far as archaeologists can determine, was the mace.

(20:38)   A heavy stone head, turned and polished, is attached to a wooden handle. You can't cut meat with a mace.  It cannot be used to harvest crops.  You cannot use it to skin an animal, dig a hole, or build a shelter.  The mace does exactly one thing .  She inflicts a concentrated blow with a blunt object on the human skull.

(20:58)   That's what it was created for.  That's all she does.  Mace heads appear in archaeological finds from the Middle East approximately 8,000–10,000 years ago.  It was at a time when settled communities with resource reserves and defined boundaries began to need protection from other people.  And you can trace the psychology of war in what happened to the mace later.

(21:19)   It ceased to be just a weapon.  She became a symbol.  During the time of the Egyptian pharaohs, the mace became a symbol of royal power itself.    The Narmer Palette, dated to around 3100 BC, shows King Nar raising a pear-shaped mace over the head of a kneeling captive. The first king we can name by title on a unified Egyptian artifact.

(21:40)   And the image he chose to represent his power was himself, ready to crush a man's skull.  The very symbol of royal power was a weapon designed for killing.  War ceased to be something that simply happened to societies.  This became how societies defined themselves.  And that brings us to another piece of evidence that we need to consider before we can answer the question.

(22:01)   Rock painting.  There are drawings on the rocks and in the caves of eastern Spain that date back to the Mesolithic and early Neolithic periods, approximately 6000–2500 BC.  These paintings are part of a tradition that archaeologists call Levantine art, and they are some of the most vivid prehistoric images found anywhere in Europe.

(22:19)   They depict animals. They depict hunting scenes.  And some of them depict something completely different.  Groups of human figures with bows running towards other groups of people also holding bows. Battle scenes, not hunting, not ritual, but combat: people shooting bows at other people.  And these scenes are not abstract.

(22:40)   They show specific formations, archers, and scattered groups converging from different directions.  They are demonstrating what appear to be organized attacks. And these are, as far as we know, the oldest visual depictions of war anywhere in the world. Meanwhile, on the other side of the planet, archaeological evidence tells its story.

(22:58)   At a site along the Tollensee River in northern Germany, amateur archaeologist Ronald Borgwarth discovered a human arm bone protruding from the bank in 1996.  A bronze arrowhead was stuck in it .  Systematic excavations began in 2007.  Researchers have found the oldest battlefield in Europe. The remains of at least 150 people, along with thousands of bone fragments, bronze arrowheads, flint points, and wooden sticks, were scattered along a 3- kilometer stretch of shore.

(23:29)   The battle took place around 1250 BC.  during the Bronze Age. Researchers suggest that about 4,000 warriors could have participated in it.  Up to 1,000 of them could have died.  The skulls have blunt force trauma consistent with wooden sticks found at the site. Fractures from severe impacts are visible on the long bones. Bronze and flint arrowheads were stuck in ribs and spines.

(23:52)   Isotopic analysis of the bones showed that some of the battle participants came hundreds of kilometers away, bearing dietary signatures, including traces of millet, indicating their origins in southern and central Europe. This was not a local conflict.  It was an organized interregional military conflict involving people traveling great distances specifically for the battle.

(24:11) Before the excavations at Tollensee, historians generally believed that Bronze Age northern Europe was a relatively peaceful trading area.  The battlefield completely disproved this assumption.  These people waged wars on a scale that historians believe was impossible for European societies of the pre-state period .

(24:29)   Now let's look at Crow Creek.  In 1978, archaeologists excavating near the Missouri River in South Dakota discovered a mass grave containing the remains of at least 486 people: men, women, and children.  Almost all of them bore signs of extreme cruelty: scalping, skull fractures, dismemberment.  The bodies were left in the open air for some time before being dumped into the settlement's own defensive ditch.

(24:55) The massacre occurred around 1325 AD , likely due to a struggle for resources during a prolonged drought.  This was not a battlefield where two armies met by agreement. It was the complete destruction of an entire community.  Now it is worth saying something more about how people invented war.  And this is something that no one likes to talk about, because the archaeological evidence —bones, weapons, fortifications— tells only what happened.

(25:20) They do not explain how this became possible.  How do you get a group of people, biologically wired for empathy, who feel pain when they see the suffering of others, to form deep social bonds with strangers?  How do you get such people to systematically kill other people who, by all measurable indicators, are no different from them ? The answer lies in a psychological mechanism that every culture on Earth has independently developed.

(25:44)   You are dehumanizing another group .  You give them a different name, a different category.  You define your group by what another group is not.  And once someone stops being part of your group, the normal rules of empathy and cooperation simply stop working.  Psychologists call this the distinction between " one's own" and "others'.

(26:02) "  And it works in every human society that has ever been studied.  From hunter- gatherer tribes to modern nation-states, it takes almost nothing to trigger this.  Different language, different appearance, different river valley, different god.  The mechanism is the same everywhere.  Draw a line.  Decide who is on which side, and then the people on the other side of that line become someone you can kill without it feeling like murder.

(26:28)   This is not a recent invention. This is not a product of civilization.  This is a feature of the human brain that seems very, very ancient.  And without it, war as we know it would be impossible, because the hardest thing about war is never creating better weapons.  The hardest part was convincing people to use it.  So, here is the answer to the question you came for.

(26:49)   Humans did not invent war the way someone invents a tool in one place, at one time, and with one clear purpose. War emerged gradually over millennia as a series of escalations.  The capacity for group violence seems ancient, perhaps even older than our species as a whole. Chimpanzees demonstrate this.    The bones at Jebel Sahaba, which are 13,400 years old, demonstrate this.

(27:14)   Nataruk, which is 10,000 years old, demonstrates this with the example of hunter-gatherers who had no farms, cities, or borders.  But the capacity for violence is not war.  War requires infrastructure.  It requires organization , leadership, logistics, and constant motivation.  And these elements have been coming together piece by piece over the last 12,000 years or so.

(27:34) Agriculture has created immovable wealth worth fighting for.  Settled communities have created boundaries worth defending.  The hierarchy created leaders who could organize and direct violence on a large scale.  And technology has created weapons designed not for hunting animals, but for killing people. The probability that war is a single, distinct invention that emerged at a single point in human history is essentially zero.

(27:59)   The likelihood that the capacity for organized group violence has deep evolutionary roots, shared with our closest primates, is very high.  Approximately 85–90% based on a confluence of archaeological, primatological, and anthropological evidence.  But whether this ability will become war depends on the conditions. The right pressure, the right social structures, the right stakes.

(28:23)   For most of human history, such conditions did not exist.  And then, about 12,000 years ago, they appeared. And once that happened, war proved to be one of the most enduring inventions our species has ever created .  The bones at Jebel Sahaba are 13,400 years old.  The walls of Jericho are 10,000 years old.  The first phalanx depicted on the Kite Stele is 4,450 years old.

(28:49)   The first recorded Battle of Megiddo took place 3,480 years ago.  And tonight, somewhere on Earth, a weapons system designed by engineers educated in universities built on taxes raised by governments created to protect borders, held by treaties signed to end wars, is being loaded, tested, and aimed at its target. Technology has changed beyond anything a Neolithic farmer could have imagined.  The reason is no.

(29:15) Someone has something.  Someone else wants to get it.  And the distance between these two facts is still measured in the same units.