A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of Randall Forsberg’s Toward a Theory of Peace:
A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of Randall Forsberg’s Toward a Theory of Peace: The Role of Moral Beliefs in the Elimination of Sanctioned Violence
Overview and Structural Framework
Randall Caroline Watson Forsberg (1943–2007) was an influential military analyst, social theorist, and peace activist who established the Nuclear Weapons Freeze Campaign in the early 1980s and founded the Institute for Defense and Disarmament Studies (IDDS). Completed as her doctoral dissertation at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in May 1997 under the supervision of Joshua Cohen and Barry Posen, her monograph Toward a Theory of Peace: The Role of Moral Beliefs was posthumously edited by political scientists Matthew Evangelista and Neta C. Crawford and published by Cornell University Press in 2019.
Forsberg's central research question investigates whether war—conceptualized not as an unalterable biological necessity, but as an institutionalized form of socially sanctioned group violence—can be permanently eradicated through the deliberate evolution of moral beliefs and cultural norms. To evaluate this thesis, she conducted an interdisciplinary inquiry synthesizing research from anthropology, archaeology, sociology, psychology, and international relations. She tracked how historically sanctioned violent institutions, including human sacrifice, ritual cannibalism, dueling, and chattel slavery, transitioned from essential cultural practices to morally repugnant, legally prohibited, and functionally extinct behaviors.
This report provides a systematic analysis of the seven theoretical and empirical dimensions that structure Forsberg's analytical architecture. These dimensions map directly onto the main structural divisions of Toward a Theory of Peace, addressing its conceptual premises, psychological foundations, empirical case studies, evolutionary models, and concrete security policy applications.
Structural Division
Primary Analytical Focus
Central Theoretical Claim
Part I, Chapter 1: The Idea of a Theory of Peace
Conceptualization of a "theory of peace" versus realpolitik and militarism1.
War is a learned cultural institution rather than a biological imperative, making its elimination possible through normative shifts2.
Part I, Chapter 2: Conditions for the Abolition of War
Prerequisites for transitioning from negative peace to permanent structural abolition3.
Abolition requires pairing the moral delegitimation of offensive force with non-provocative defense postures and democratic institutions4.
Part II, Chapter 3: Innate Impulses vs. Learned Moral Beliefs
Psychological drivers of individual aggression versus organized group violence5.
Individual aggressive impulses do not cause warfare; organized mass violence depends entirely on learned moral sanctioning6.
Part II, Chapter 4: Features and Sources of Sanctioned Violence
Typology, structural characteristics, and social functions of sanctioned killing5.
Sanctioned violence requires institutional legitimacy, public ritual, elite organization, and collective moral exemption7.
Part II, Chapter 5: Ritual Cannibalism Case Study
Ethnographic evaluation of customary cannibalism across diverse societal samples5.
Embedded violent institutions undergo total normative extinction when moral beliefs evolve to recognize victim humanity8.
Part II, Chapter 6: Morality and Cultural Evolution
Macro-level mechanisms of normative change across historical epochs9.
Cultural evolution follows a multi-phase trajectory where moral re-evaluation turns socially approved violence into taboo10.
Question 1: The Nature and Definition of a Theory of Peace
The conceptualization of a "theory of peace" marks a departure from conventional international relations paradigms, which historically prioritized the mechanics of war and state power. Political realism posits that the anarchic structure of the international system renders war an immutable feature of human organization, defining peace narrowly as "negative peace"—the transient absence of active hostilities maintained through coercive deterrence or a balance of power.
Forsberg redefines a theory of peace as an explanatory paradigm that identifies the precise socio-cultural, moral, and structural conditions under which the institution of war itself can be rendered obsolete. Rather than treating warfare as a biological inevitability or an unavoidable consequence of state sovereignty, she categorizes it as a socially constructed tool developed at a specific stage of human cultural evolution. A viable theory of peace must demonstrate how changing moral beliefs delegitimize violent institutions and how nonviolent structural alternatives are established to manage human conflict.
Crucial to Forsberg’s theoretical foundation is the analytical decoupling of individual human hostility from organized state violence. Realist frameworks frequently conflate personal aggressive drives with international conflict, implying that until individual human nature is altered, war must persist. Forsberg demonstrates that organized warfare requires sophisticated administrative planning, institutional infrastructure, public financing, and formal moral authorization from political or religious elites. Achieving peace does not require eliminating human aggressive emotions, but rather withdrawing social, legal, and moral legitimacy from the institution of war.
Forsberg's methodology relies heavily on Habermasian discourse ethics and empirical rationalism. She posits that public discourse, grounded in transparent, verifiable data regarding military capabilities and defense expenditures, possesses the capacity to reframe societal moral understanding. Exposing the contradiction between national security claims and the reality of mutual destruction serves as an empirical catalyst for normative change.
Question 2: Structural and Normative Prerequisites for the Abolition of War
Achieving a permanent end to warfare requires a combination of internal moral transformations and external institutional structures. Forsberg outlines a framework in which moral shifts delegitimize the use of force, while structural mechanisms provide security without reliance on offensive military power.
On the normative level, the essential condition for war abolition is the universalization of a moral prohibition against deploying organized violence for territorial acquisition, political dominance, ideological expansion, or pre-emptive gain. Human societies have already established strict domestic moral and legal prohibitions against individual violence and murder. The remaining normative barrier is the international double standard that grants sovereign states a moral exemption to commit mass violence under the umbrella of national defense. Abolishing war requires extending domestic moral prohibitions against killing to state-sanctioned international force.
On the structural level, moral changes must be reinforced by institutional arrangements that alleviate the security dilemma. If states fear external conquest, moral commitments to nonviolence can collapse under strategic pressure. Forsberg identifies three structural prerequisites to prevent this instability:
First, states must transition their armed forces away from power-projection capabilities toward strictly non-provocative defensive configurations. Redesigning military postures so that forces are optimized for home defense while physically incapable of cross-border invasion dismantles the offensive threat perception that drives international arms races.
Second, international institutions must provide binding, transparent mechanisms for conflict resolution. Multilateral judicial bodies, international arbitration, and verifiable verification frameworks must replace military force as the recognized standard for settling territorial, economic, and political disputes.
Third, internal democratic governance and executive accountability must be institutionalized globally. Authoritarian political systems permit small ruling elites to mobilize state resources for aggressive military campaigns without civilian consent. Broadening civil participation, legislative oversight, and democratic power-sharing reduces state inclination toward external aggression, establishing the domestic conditions necessary for durable international peace.
Question 3: Innate Impulses Versus Learned Moral Beliefs in Human Violence
A persistent argument against the possibility of peace contends that human beings possess an innate biological drive for lethal aggression that renders war inevitable. Forsberg conducts an interdisciplinary critique of biological determinism, drawing on psychological, anthropological, and neurological evidence to establish that organized warfare is driven by learned moral beliefs rather than biological programming.
Forsberg establishes a distinction between basic biological impulses—such as anger, fear, territorial defense, and frustration—and the complex, highly coordinated behaviors required to execute state warfare. While emotional reactions like rage or self-defense have evolutionary roots in human neurobiology, these individual impulses manifest as brief, unorganized outbursts. Organized warfare, by contrast, requires participants to suppress spontaneous emotional reactions and overcome deep-seated psychological inhibitions against killing fellow human beings.
Individual Biological Impulses
- Spontaneous, unorganized emotional responses (rage, fear, self-defense)
- Natural psychological aversion to close-range killing of human beings
│
▼ (Intervened by institutional socialization & moral framing)
Learned Moral Beliefs & Social Sanctioning
- Systemic ideological indoctrination, ritualized training, and hierarchical discipline
- Enables organized mass mobilization, state warfare, and institutionalized killing
To carry out sustained combat, military institutions must systematically overcome natural human empathy through ritualized training, hierarchical discipline, moral disengagement, and ideological indoctrination. Soldiers participate in modern combat not due to personal fits of uncontrollable rage, but because they have been socialized to fulfill institutional duty, obey legal authority, and view state-sanctioned violence as morally necessary.
Learned moral beliefs serve as the primary operational variable governing human group violence. Because moral beliefs are transmitted through cultural socialization rather than biological genetics, they remain responsive to historical re-evaluation. When a culture alters its moral frameworks and withdraws ethical authorization from violent practices, the incidence of those practices collapses, regardless of underlying human emotional drives.
Question 4: Conceptualizing Socially Sanctioned Group Violence
To analyze how violent practices end, Forsberg establishes a conceptual framework around "socially sanctioned group violence". She defines this phenomenon as organized physical force that is authorized, legitimized, and regulated by a society's dominant moral, religious, or political institutions.
Unlike unsanctioned violence—such as criminal homicide or unauthorized assault—sanctioned violence is morally praised, socially rewarded, and framed as vital to collective survival or spiritual order. Individuals performing sanctioned violence are granted moral and legal immunity for actions that would otherwise be severely punished under domestic criminal law.
Form of Violence
Dominant Historical Context
Primary Social Function
Mechanism of Sanctioning
Current Normative Status
Human Sacrifice
Aztec Empire, Ancient Carthage.
Preservation of cosmic order, political intimidation, elite control.
Religious mandates, priestly rituals, sacred obligation.
Economic labor extraction, racial and class hierarchy.
State legal codes, racial dogmas, police powers.
Universally Outlawed.
Judicial Torture & Dueling
Early Modern Europe, Early America.
Extraction of legal confession, aristocratic honor restoration.
Formal judicial procedure, aristocratic codes of honor.
Formally Delegitimized.
Interstate Warfare
Modern State System.
Territorial expansion, national defense, regime survival.
Sovereign defense laws, military oaths, national ideology.
Active, but Normatively Restricted.
Forsberg identifies four universal features that characterize all forms of socially sanctioned group violence:
First, the practice relies on explicit institutional authorization from established authorities, such as state executives, tribal councils, or religious leaders, distinguishing it from individual impulse.
Second, the practice involves a systemic moral inversion, wherein standard moral prohibitions against causing harm are suspended, and refusing to participate in the violence is punished as treason, heresy, or cowardice.
Third, the violence is governed by formal codification and public ritual, specifying valid targets, allowed weapons, and boundaries to maintain social control.
Fourth, the practice is justified through perceived social utility, maintained by collective beliefs that the violence is necessary for economic security, divine favor, or national defense.
Question 5: Ritual Cannibalism as an Empirical Case Study in Normative Eradication
In Chapter 5, Forsberg presents a detailed anthropological analysis of ritual cannibalism to evaluate how deeply embedded violent traditions disappear. Skeptics of war abolition frequently argue that when a violent institution is integrated into a society's religion, economy, and cultural identity, it becomes a permanent fixture of that culture. Forsberg selects ritual cannibalism specifically because it represents a violent institution that was historically practiced across multiple independent societies.
Through an examination of cross-cultural ethnographic data across distinct linguistic groupings—including Hokan, Salishan, and Aztec-Tanoan societies—Forsberg documents how customary cannibalism operated as a fully sanctioned social institution. The practice was categorized into exocannibalism (the consumption of enemy combatants to absorb spiritual power or signal total conquest) and endocannibalism (the consumption of deceased kin during funerary rituals as an act of ancestral respect).
In an appendix evaluating the academic debate introduced by anthropologist William Arens—who argued that accounts of customary cannibalism were largely imperial fabrications designed to justify colonial conquest—Forsberg analyzes the underlying empirical records. She concludes that while European colonizers frequently exaggerated claims to vilify indigenous populations, authentic, institutionally sanctioned ritual cannibalism was historically documented across independent cultures through archaeological, forensic, and ethnographic evidence.
The theoretical significance of the cannibalism case study lies in the structural mechanics of its complete demise. Ritual cannibalism did not end due to genetic shifts or biological changes in human anatomy. It collapsed because intercultural communication, moral re-evaluation, and changing ethical beliefs altered how societies understood the basic humanity and personhood of others. As cannibalism came to be viewed as morally repulsive, it was rapidly stigmatized, outlawed, and eliminated from acceptable human behavior. Forsberg contends that if an institution as culturally internalized as ritual cannibalism can undergo total normative extinction, the institution of war can follow an identical path toward abolition.
Question 6: Cultural Evolution and the Stigmatization Mechanism
Forsberg synthesizes her findings into a macro-level model of cultural evolution, explaining how changing moral beliefs systematically transform socially approved violence into universal taboos. Rejecting sociobiological frameworks that attribute cultural changes to genetic selection, she constructs a model of normative cultural evolution driven by cognitive moral development, ethical reflection, and social advocacy.
Phase of Evolution
Operational Mechanism
Historical Instance (Slavery / Sacrifice)
Modern Application to Warfare
1. Unquestioned Acceptance
Violence is viewed as natural, divinely ordained, or essential for survival.
Chattel slavery viewed as a natural condition of human hierarchy.
War accepted as legitimate statecraft and balance-of-power policy.
2. Moral Critique & Advocacy
Reformers exposure ethical contradictions and human costs.
Abolitionists frame slavery as morally incompatible with human rights.
Peace movements frame nuclear weapons and warfare as existential threats.
3. Institutional Restraint
Legal limits and boundary conditions are imposed on the practice.
Regulation of slave working conditions and bans on international slave trade.
Geneva Conventions, laws of armed conflict, nuclear test-ban treaties.
4. Broad Stigmatization
Moral re-evaluation renders the practice socially unacceptable.
Slavery comes to be viewed with universal ethical repulsion.
Universal stigmatization of conquest, chemical arms, and nuclear use.
5. Structural Abolition
Complete legal prohibition and formal dismantle of institutional capacity.
International legal codification banning human ownership.
Global treaty prohibition of war and structural transition to defense-only forces.
This evolutionary model demonstrates that moral progress follows a clear progression. Initial moral critiques articulated by minority reform movements highlight the contradictions within accepted violent practices. As public awareness expands, societies enter intermediate phases characterized by institutional regulation and legal boundary-setting. Over time, regulatory efforts prove insufficient to satisfy changing moral standards, triggering a transition where the violent institution is recognized as intrinsically illegitimate and is formally dismantled.
Forsberg places modern warfare in the middle stages of this evolutionary trajectory. International legal frameworks, such as the United Nations Charter and the Geneva Conventions, demonstrate that global society has already begun restricting the legal parameters of state force. The final phase of cultural evolution requires moving beyond the regulation of armed conflict to the structural prohibition of war as an acceptable instrument of state policy.
Question 7: Strategic Implications for Arms Control, Defense Postures, and Peacebuilding
Forsberg connected her theoretical model directly to contemporary international security policy, arms control negotiations, and post-conflict peacebuilding. Her analysis provided the theoretical framework for her practical work with the Nuclear Weapons Freeze Campaign and the Institute for Defense and Disarmament Studies.
Forsberg’s research generates three primary strategic applications for security analysts and policymakers:
Theoretical Framework: Moral Delegitimation of Sanctioned Violence
│
├── Intermediate Policy 1: Bilateral Nuclear Freeze & Arsenal Reductions
├── Intermediate Policy 2: Transition to Non-Provocative Defensive Postures (NPD)
└── Intermediate Policy 3: Inclusive Institutional Peacebuilding & Shared Vulnerability
│
▼
Final Strategic Outcome: Permanent Structural Abolition of Interstate Warfare
First, the Nuclear Weapons Freeze serves as an intermediate strategy for halting arms races. Recognizing that immediate, unilateral disarmament was politically unattainable, Forsberg designed the Freeze initiative to halt the testing, production, and deployment of nuclear weapons simultaneously across major powers. Halting the technological momentum of modern weaponry creates strategic stability, lowering mutual suspicion and opening political avenues for negotiated arsenal reductions.
Second, implementing Non-Provocative Defense (NPD) addresses the structural security dilemma between states. Non-provocative defense requires restructuring national armed forces so that defensive capabilities are maintained while long-range offensive systems are removed. Adjusting force structures, logistical supply chains, and weapons inventories so that a nation can defend its own territory but lacks the airlift, heavy armor, and strike ranges required for cross-border invasion eliminates threat perceptions among neighboring states, paving the way for systematic reductions in military spending.
Third, applying this normative model to post-conflict peacebuilding emphasizes the importance of managing mutual vulnerability during peace accord implementation. Quantitative studies of civil war settlements indicate that peace agreements achieve long-term stability when political, economic, and military vulnerability is balanced equally among former combatants.
Furthermore, political leadership transitions strongly influence implementation success: "insider" leaders who maintain institutional continuity facilitate peace agreements, whereas hawkish political turnover can destabilize settlements if commitment mechanisms are not structurally protected. Successful long-term peacebuilding requires combining multilateral verification with inclusive governance, economic development, and democratic civil control to ensure that compliance remains more advantageous than returning to armed conflict.
Synthesis and Conclusions
Randall Caroline Watson Forsberg’s Toward a Theory of Peace: The Role of Moral Beliefs delivers a thorough theoretical and empirical critique of the assumption that warfare is an unalterable aspect of human social organization. By analyzing war as a form of socially sanctioned group violence, she demonstrates that mass organized conflict relies on learned moral beliefs, state authorization, and institutional socialization.
The historical evidence presented throughout her work—including the structural eradication of customary cannibalism, human sacrifice, chattel slavery, and judicial dueling—confirms that human societies repeatedly abandon deeply entrenched violent institutions once those practices lose their moral legitimacy. Achieving the structural abolition of war requires pursuing two parallel trajectories:
First, expanding the moral delegitimation of state violence, establishing global civic norms that view state-sanctioned mass killing as morally equivalent to murder, thereby stripping war of its institutional legitimacy.
Second, implementing non-provocative defense configurations, binding multilateral dispute-resolution mechanisms, and verifiable disarmament treaties to provide security without relying on offensive military force.
Combining empirical military analysis with a framework of normative cultural evolution, Forsberg’s research provides both the theoretical justification and the policy orientation required to guide international security away from organized warfare toward permanent, structural peace.